
Tracy Morgan, The Fall and Rise of Reggie Dinkins
Scott Gries/NBC
Everyone knows that there is no better way to ruin a joke than to explain it. Fewer people, however, know that telling a stranger that something is funny is perhaps the worst way to convince them it is, in fact, funny. Humor, after all, is subjective, and assuming you know someone’s subjective experience of the world is a great way to offend them. This can put the TV critic in a strange bind, as it’s not really our job to be funny, but it is our job to tell you about funny shows. Perhaps you see the predicament here. It’s a shame I’m not very funny.
The Fall and Rise of Reggie Dinkins, however, is a funny show, and it is funny in such dazzling and varied ways that I am confident we can find one that is funny to you.
Let’s begin with pedigree: The NBC sitcom, now in its second season, makes a good case for possessing the highest joke density on a sitcom since Girls5eva ended its run in 2024, in part because of the DNA it shares with that show. Both comedies are proud carriers of the 30 Rock legacy, with a deep bench of alumni among their producers and writers (and in Dinkins‘ case, star Tracy Morgan). This means Reggie Dinkins has a number of sister shows that serve as good points of comparison. Do you like 30 Rock, Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt, and Great News? Terrific. You’ll have fun here.
However, there’s more to The Fall and Rise of Reggie Dinkins than celebrated talent continuing their good work. Its premise — in which the disgraced arthouse documentarian Arthur Tobin (Daniel Radcliffe) is hired to film a documentary about former football star Reggie Dinkins (Morgan) to fuel his comeback post-gambling scandal — is the perfect engine for a sitcom, enough to give every episode a sense of direction and conflict, but not so restrictive that it takes over the show. In fact, Reggie Dinkins is the rare mockumentary that doesn’t feel the need to always appear as a documentary — it is merely a documentary when that is the funniest thing to be. Most times, this means embarrassing Arthur Tobin — a role in which Radcliffe is routinely superb, an odd little worm of a man trying his best to appear normal, unaware that he can never do that in a home full of oddballs.
Because Reggie Dinkins is a show about an extraordinarily strange blended family. Dinkins lives with his son Carmelo (Jalyn Hall), fiancée Brina (Precious Way), and best friend Rusty (Bobby Moynihan, as funny as he’s ever been). Also still in the picture is Reggie’s ex-wife Monica (Erika Alexander), working as his manager and trying very hard to not get caught up in anyone’s antics, to no avail. This is a gold mine of chaotic relationships where every combination of characters is great for jokes. There’s some uncommonly sharp generation gap humor between Monica and the much younger Brina, and the ways they relate to Carmelo (with Brina much more comfortable being cutthroat toward the very sweet teenager). Rusty does his best to be a river to his people despite being a lazy leech, trying very hard to make up for it by being everyone’s best friend. Which is at odds with his actual status of being Reggie’s best friend. And Reggie? Reggie is an avatar of blissful obliviousness, forever perplexed by the chaos that surrounds him while completely unaware that he has often precipitated it.
ALSO READ: The complete guide to fall TV
With all of these tools at its disposal, The Fall and Rise of Reggie Dinkins has developed an astonishing knack for comedy that’s rooted in character but also has bandwidth for topical gags (one episode this season references a viral, debunked rumor that Shakira discovered her ex was cheating after a jar of her favorite jam went missing) and physical comedy (Arthur’s completely unnecessary yet perfectly executed Double Kong Vault as he attempts to escape an angry security guard) in equal measure. Did I mention that it’s also very committed to constant sports jokes, like naming Reggie’s former NFL rival Jerry Basmati (and casting Craig Robinson to play him)?
There’s a tremendous snowballing of funny that can happen when Reggie Dinkins writers and cast members are using all of their available riches to pack its 10-episode seasons to the brim with every trick they can think of in order to wring gags out of a show malleable enough to accommodate just about every way there is to be funny on TV. It’s got the charm of a broadcast sitcom with the weirder, more rangy impulses of a streaming one, a dazzling blend of old and new approaches. It’s a comedy that shows how far TV comedy has come, while also being as traditional as it gets, doing whatever it can to make you laugh.
The Fall and Rise of Reggie Dinkins airs Mondays at 8:30/7:30c on NBC and streams on Peacock.
