Wow, what a way to go into the winter break. I loved a lot of this episode, the theatrics of all of it and that it felt like I was watching a movie; however, personally I really didn’t like the many implications that Martin has to change who he is.
The show has always been pretty heavy on the fact that Martin isn’t like everyone else, and yes, most of it is motivated by his own feelings, but I kind of wanted someone to say that he doesn’t have to change who he is. He isn’t Dr Reece and he shouldn’t try to be because he is his own person.
I did appreciate the fact that most of the motivation came from Martin’s own insecurities rather than the town forcing him to be different like they have in the past; I just wish we didn’t have to see him constantly change who he is just to fit in. It’s always better to be unique than to be like everyone else.
With that main rant over, this episode in general was great despite my aforementioned personal feelings. There were so many great moments and some much-needed comic relief moments; I don’t know where the ending leaves us, but I was incredibly impressed by it.
Let’s start with the beginning of this episode. I am so glad that the first sequence showed up as a scene from two years ago. I truly thought that it was a dream that Louisa was having and that she would wake up kissing Mark instead of Martin and be really confused.
Thankfully, it wasn’t that, and then we got the really sweet moment between them when they discussed the kiss. I really liked the fact that we picked up the next day, which means we actually get to see everything unfold together rather than just jumping straight to them being together.
I need to see more of Sarah and Judith together because those two are incredible. I truly could not stop laughing at everything they were doing. It’s so fun to watch two people deeply care for each other but non-stop bickering like siblings. Judith threatening Sarah with a knife when she is there to keep her away from sharp objects was hilarious, and Judith coming back into the house asking if they’re still on for Friday after their fight was the cherry on top.
I am so glad that Louisa and Mark have managed to work out a way to be friends and not have any animosity between the two of them. That conversation between the two of them in the treehouse was so heartfelt and lovely to see them both finally articulate how they actually feel about the breakdown of their relationship. I love them as friends and I can’t wait to see more of that for them.
It was great to have Peter Cronk back with Doc again, even if it didn’t really pay off until the puppy scene. It was nice to see them reconcile a little bit after so many episodes apart. Plus, who doesn’t love puppies (maybe Martin)?

“Back To The Suture” – BEST MEDICINE. Pictured: Annie Potts as Aunt Sarah, Cree Cicchino as Elaine, Josh Charles as Martin Best Photo: Danielle Mathias/FOX
That last sequence left me absolutely speechless. I am relieved that Sarah is okay and that Elaine was able to save her. That last scene between Martin and Louisa was so emotional. I am genuinely in awe of Josh Charles in that scene because somehow he managed to just completely show the dissociation Doc was having by just staring in one spot.
I seriously do not know where Martin is going to go after this because currently he seems like he is in complete shut-down mode, understandably so, and I don’t think at the moment he is going to be okay with continuing being the town’s doctor.
It seems like everything regarding ‘caring’ for the town and ‘caring’ about the town seem to all melt together at the end of this episode when he couldn’t save someone he cares about. My heart broke for him so much in that last scene. I am so happy that Louisa could be there for him in that moment regardless of whether he was talking to her or not.
I don’t know where we are going to pick up after the break in January, but this definitely ensures that I am waiting with bated breath for the show to return.
