Thursday, June 4, 2026
HomeSpoilersNCIS: Sydney Season 3 Episode 10 Review: An Eye for an Eye…...

NCIS: Sydney Season 3 Episode 10 Review: An Eye for an Eye… A Son for a Son

- Advertisment -

Are we surprised that the NCIS: Sydney crew would totally fail an HR workplace culture test?

They’re a bit unorthodox, and the environment they foster isn’t exactly textbook, but that’s why we love them in the first place.

Where they shine is in handling some of the most complicated cases, and taking on Carter’s son’s case was most definitely complicated.

(Daniel Asher Smith/Paramount+ )

The Carter investigation was interesting because the immediate situation that came to mind was the heartbreaking death of Gabby Petito. I wouldn’t be surprised if that was something they were angling for when constructing this particular case.

This story also resulted in a tragedy, but the angle they worked for it was interesting enough, as it was less about infidelity, domestic abuse, or even drugs, and all about how far a hurt man would go to seek revenge.

  • The Pendragon Cycle: Rise of the Merlin Left Merlin in a Battle of Wills
  • ‘Star City’ First Look Photos Unveil the New ‘For All Mankind’ Spinoff
  • The Pitt Season 2’s Unfillable Collins Void is Officially Impossible to Ignore (And Damning)

The hour was also decent in regards to giving us more insight into Carter, who is admittedly someone I don’t typically think about much at all.

He often feels like a bit of a hardass, and there are times when he also feels like a thorn in their side. However, this installment put into perspective that he’s not just a guy who likes to ride their case or impede how they do their jobs.

He’s a man of principle, almost to a fault in the eyes of those around him, and it’s a different way of looking at him than I ever had before.

(Daniel Asher Smith/Paramount+ )

A man who wouldn’t bend the rules even for his own son, knowing that he was facing a murder charge?

Yeah, that’s a man of principles and values, and it’s a refreshing change of pace from most law enforcement in fictional dramas like this.

By the end of the hour, he even apologized for dragging Mackey and the others into this, as it shouldn’t have been under their scope in the first place.

Carter had some stumbles along the way — it was still dicey on his part that he didn’t immediately call Mackey or tell her right out that Miles had returned to them at that hotel. It didn’t look great on his part, but it was also just a waste of resources.

And his going off alone in search of Clifford to confront him on his own was another moment where he slipped up.

But ultimately, he’s a man who stands by his values and walks the line, and not even a man coming for his son brought out the worst in him.

(Daniel Asher Smith/Paramount+ )

Ironically, it’s exactly what landed Miles in danger, potentially at the mercy of the Australian court system, and resulted in the death of his girlfriend, Sophie.

Grieving the loss of a child is one thing, but how did Clifford rationalize killing an innocent part like Sophie for the sole purpose of setting Miles up to send him to prison?

  • The Rookie: Chenford Works Better With Tim’s Mom in the Picture
  • Chicago Fire Handled That Death Just Right — Yes, I Take It All Back
  • Bridgerton Season 5 Theories: The New Lady Whistledown, Ton Power Shifts & Who’s Next: Eloise or Francesca?

It’s just so sick! He brutally murdered her, too — just a nice, sweet young woman who was traveling around the country with her boyfriend and living her best life.

Everyone had to suffer because Clifford suffered the loss of his son, which, while tragic, didn’t mitigate why his son was in prison and what happened.

Miles woke up with no memory, a bloody knife in his hand, his van being a full-on crime scene, a dead girlfriend, and the genuine fear that he could go down for it.

(Daniel Asher Smith/Paramount+ )

It’s going to take him a long time to move past that, as there will never be any “getting over” it.

But at least he has Carter there to help him through, and you can trust that he will guide his son through the best way he knows how. It’s within his principles to do so.

It’s too bad Clifford couldn’t figure out the same thing with his own son.

Instead, he felt punishing Carter for not breaking the law and covering for him and his son would be the solution to ease his pain.

And then, when that didn’t work, he wanted Carter to ruin himself and his reputation by killing him in cold blood.

Imagine where he would’ve been if he had opted for therapy instead of revenge.

(Daniel Asher Smith/Paramount+ )

A little background on Carter was great. And there were some exciting moments.

Mackey and JD are always a perfect partnership when they’re beating the path together and working on something.

  • Shrinking Season 3 Episode 7 Review: Give Us Something To Sing About
  • RJ Decker Season 1 Episode 2 Lays the Perfect Trap and Captures Our Hearts
  • NCIS: Sydney Season 3 Episode 10 Review: An Eye for an Eye… A Son for a Son

It always makes me wary because we’re just waiting for the other shoe to drop when JD learns about what Mackey has been keeping from them.

They trust each other implicitly out in the field, no questions asked, but we’ve also been noticing the silent, subtle erosion there all of NCIS: Sydney Season 3.

JD knew something was up and tracked Mackey down, which is him being a good partner but also an indicator that he’s still uneasy with her in some regard.

(Daniel Asher Smith/Paramount+ )

I’m just curious to see how their partnership will fare by the end of the season.

Their fixation on this case and their convenient bailing on the HR thing was amusing, though.

It also made me think — in some ways, their missing it felt like a sign. And the fact that they are faking team-building rather than actually doing it is also interesting.

Evie and DeShawn don’t have trust issues out in the field. When they’re serious and locked in, they’re always in step with each other. It’s the personal stuff that’s making them suffer.

They don’t trust each other with vulnerability. The two of them both use humor to deflect, but Evie especially leans into that too much, especially during serious moments.

(Daniel Asher Smith/Paramount+ )

Her antics during the culture class were peak Evie. At no point did she take things even remotely close to serious, except, maybe, when DeShawn actually committed to the role-playing.

They definitely threw that bone out there for those who ship this pairing romantically. And the tension in that moment was certainly entertaining.

DeShawn’s rizz? Unmatched in that moment. You could tell Evie was affected by how sincere he sounded, and who can blame her? It would’ve worked on me!

  • RJ Decker’s Jaina Lee Ortiz Talks Emi’s Wild Entrance, RJ’s Irresistible Allure & the Enigmatic Ochoas
  • Bevin Bru Talks Bringing Order to RJ Decker’s Chaos, Unorthodox Families & Peak Florida Weirdness
  • Constance Zimmer Talks Ann’s Protective Instincts on Love Story Season 1 Episode 6, “The Wedding”

But just as they were leaning in closer, wrapped in the moment, with Blue and Trigger as riveted by this as the rest of us, the HR lady ended the “scene.”

One could argue that part of the reason Evie treats DeShawn the way she does, and has upped the ante with her antagonistic, at times obnoxious behavior this season, is that she may have feelings for him.

It’s scary to have those, so doubling down on the annoying behavior is a perfect way to put up walls and guard her heart and feelings. She doesn’t have to be vulnerable when she’s being silly.

( Daniel Asher Smith/Paramount+ )

Deflection and distraction.

I do have to hand it to the HR lady; she had them both pegged incredibly well. I love bits like that.

The trigger of it all was hilarious, though. Her thinking that his name was actually him admitting that she was triggering him made me giggle.

But whereas DeShawn and Edie have underlying issues they don’t want to address, Trigger and Blue performed well during the trust exercises.

Blue is very trusting of this batch of people, and Trigger is pretty dependable. Of course, my Blue Trigger/Triger Blue, True (?) shipper heart adores the little moments we have them.

If only NCIS: Sydney delivered on the pairing. Pretty please!

(Daniel Asher Smith/Paramount+)

But did anyone else read too much into the ending with Trigger and Evie? Does she think he was asking her out?

Over to you, NCIS: Sydney Fanatics!

Did you enjoy this Carter-centric episode? Do you think NCIS: Sydney still needs to do something about Evie?

Were there sparks between her and DeShawn or her and Trigger? Let’s discuss below!

Rate NCIS: Sydney Season 3 Episode 10
Vote
×
  • NCIS: Sydney Season 3 Episode 10 Review: An Eye for an Eye… A Son for a Son

    NCIS: Sydney Season 3 Episode 10 Review: An Eye for an Eye… A Son for a Son

    Mackey and JD are pulled into a murder investigation that hits close to home on NCIS: Sydney Season 3 Episode 10 and the team deals with HR training.

  • NCIS: Origins Season 2 Episode 10 Proves the Kids Are Alright in a Crisis

    NCIS: Origins Season 2 Episode 10 Proves the Kids Are Alright in a Crisis

    An unexpected biohazard situation results in a lockdown with Gibbs in charge on NCIS: Origins Season 2 Episode 10, putting him to the test.

  • NCIS Season 23 Episode 11 Continues to Connect to Character’s Pasts

    NCIS Season 23 Episode 11 Continues to Connect to Character’s Pasts

    NCIS Season 23 has brought some nostalgia, connecting back to the pasts of various characters. That connection continues during NCIS Season …

  • Fanatic Feed: Brooke Shields’ You’re Killing Me First Look, Fire Country & Sheriff Country Crossover, & More

    Fanatic Feed: Brooke Shields’ You’re Killing Me First Look, Fire Country & Sheriff Country Crossover, & More

    We have some exciting TV news, including an interesting new show for Brooke Shields, a Fire Country/Sheriff Country crossover, and more!

  • CIA Season 1 Episode 3 Brings a Standard Case to Show the Trust Within the Fusion Cell

    CIA Season 1 Episode 3 Brings a Standard Case to Show the Trust Within the Fusion Cell

    While the case of the week seems a little standard and cliche, CIA Season 1 Episode 3 puts the focus on the team working together.

TV Fanatic is searching for passionate contributors to share their voices across various article types. Think you have what it takes to be a TV Fanatic? Click here for more information and next steps.

The post NCIS: Sydney Season 3 Episode 10 Review: An Eye for an Eye… A Son for a Son appeared first on TV Fanatic.

RELATED ARTICLES
- Advertisment -

Most Popular

Recent Comments