Critic’s Rating: 4.8 / 5.0
4.8
Even if we never get another season, I’m glad I watched this spinoff.
The series did not make a massive impression with its first two episodes, but it found its footing by Star City Season 1 Episode 4, and I was completely hooked.
Having come to expect nothing short of pure excellence from this creative team, I find Episode 8, “The Wolves,” to be a perfect, devastating conclusion to a stellar thriller.
Being kept completely in the dark is one of the greatest achievements a paranoid spy thriller can pull off, and I’ve been unable to guess what the next hour would bring all season.
I was utterly hypnotized by everything that unfolded in this final hour — it is exciting, shocking, emotional, and profoundly affirming.
This volatile mix of emotions makes for an incredibly satisfying end to the story.
The finale immediately answers the burning question of how Sasha, Valya, and Chadha survived the explosion.
Space has a way of warping physics, and an explosion that realistically should have turned everyone aboard that ship into minced meat lacked the concentrated force to inflict fatal structural damage.
Accepting the explanation requires a slight leap of faith, but the Venera 3 crew members are undeniably the luckiest souls in the cosmos.
They are lucky in the most random sense of the word, but also because they have desperate people fighting in their corner.
Surviving for months in the void of space is no minor feat, and navigating a re-entry sequence while actively being hunted by their own government should have been impossible.
But at some point, luck runs out, and for Valya, the writing was always on the wall.
There was simply no clean way out for Valya here.
He is a traitor, even if his motivations were entirely selfless. Yet, it is this exact selflessness that allows his colleagues to successfully return to Earth while he is crushed to death on the surface of Venus.
Against all odds, the Chief Designer and his Eagles actually pulled it off.
They made it to Venus and back, successfully landing a man to boot.
Tragically, because he never stepped foot outside the landing craft, this monumental triumph will remain a buried state secret, known only to a select, silent few. It is heartbreaking and heartwarming in equal measure.
This final hour perfectly synthesizes everything this series has excelled at all season: hard science fiction, ruthless bureaucratic politics, and the enduring resilience of humanity.
Every single problem is solved, but never without a steep cost — be it life or freedom.
The emotional weight of the human relationships established in Star City Season 1 Episode 7 is weaponized here; Sergei’s profound loyalty to the Chief Designer is cruelly exploited in one of the finale’s most heartbreaking sequences.
Yet, even in the suffocating doom and gloom of a regime hellbent on erasing its own people from existence, human perseverance manages to shine.
Anastasia literally maneuvers her way through the vacuum of space to assist her husband. It is deeply moving to watch her fellow cosmonauts defiantly take her side because, in that tense moment, they are speaking a universal language.
They know that if the tables were turned — and after this act of mutiny, they very well might be soon — they would want someone in their corner, too.
Above all, they respect the sheer magnitude of the Venera mission.
This hour is a stark reminder that the raw mathematics and engineering required to ensure a spacecraft doesn’t simply drift off into the infinite void is an astounding accomplishment.
Perhaps in the future, someone in this alternate timeline will design a spacesuit that allows a human to walk on Venus’ surface without being flattened. That day is not today.
Today is entirely about the math and the sacrifice.
Anastasia knows exactly what grim fate awaits her on the ground, but some historical moments are simply too massive to pass up. She refuses to let Sasha down when they have already beaten steep odds.
From an initially forced, state-arranged union to surviving literal death, an entire lifetime of trauma has unfolded between them. She would be letting herself down if she didn’t intervene.
Their absolute dedication to one another — culminating in Sasha’s decision to trade his own freedom for her safety — is as impressive as it is confounding.
Even the Night Witch herself seemed quietly stunned by their selflessness.
And as we know, it is next to impossible to impress Lyudmilla.
I don’t think she would have enjoyed dragging their cold, dead bodies back to Star City any more than she did watching Sasha willingly turn himself over to her custody.
Is it true love? The show hasn’t given us quite enough information to definitively declare that, but an unbreakable bond exists there — something that completely transcends standard romance.
But in the end, Star City serves as a stark reminder that absolutely no one gets away clean in the Soviet Union.
Tanya mistakenly believed she had successfully escaped to the safety of Paris, but the KGB still has its eyes locked on her.
After all, who would suspect a Black woman in Paris of being a deep-cover Russian operative? Not even the world’s best detectives.
It’s a chilling note to end the season on, punctuating the victory with a sudden, suffocating reminder of the KGB’s reach.
It is an incredible way to close out Star City Season 1 with a lingering cloud of danger. I would normally conclude that everyone has been handed the worst possible fate, but Star City is anything but predictable.
We know the narrative has barely scratched the surface of what’s to come with Sergei and Irina, leaving plenty of narrative runway left to explore.
I desperately hope Apple TV gives Matt Wolpert, Ben Nedivi, and Ronald D. Moore the green light to continue this magnificent story.
Gut Check
“Wolves” is a flawless conclusion to this chapter of the alternate space race. Once again, I have zero negative notes—ten across the board.
Intrusive Thoughts
- Finnish border guard requirement: Age 12 to 16; No beard.
- If someone had told Yulia and her husband what that day would bring, they would have had them committed to an asylum.
- So they just pummeled some random guy? Chances are, his biggest crime was looking vaguely like the Chief Designer.
Over to you, Star City Fanatics. That was our season. What did you think of the finale? Who do you think will survive if Season 2 happens?
Let’s keep the conversation going — it’s the only way the good stuff survives.
Say something in the comments, share if you’re moved to, and keep reading. Independent voices need readers like you.
-
Remembering threatens everything on Silo Season 3 Episode 2, but Juliette and Charlotte need to grasp at the small threads.
-
Sugar Season 2 Episode 4 reveals Ray Vega’s true colors as Ji Moon escapes death, bringing Fire Sale’s dangerous conspiracy closer than ever.
-
Cape Fear Season 1 Episode 7 takes a hard left turn and does irreparable damage to the limited series. Let’s break it all down.
