Stuart Bloom spent 12 seasons on The Big Bang Theory as the guy standing just outside the group photo, close enough to matter but never quite pulled into the frame.
Now HBO Max has handed him a comic-book multiverse and the very fate of reality, and somehow that still isn’t the strangest thing happening to him.
Ever noticed Stuart Fails to Save the Universe’s opening credits?
Sure, it is not Game of Thrones level epic, but there’s something interesting going on with it.
Every single episode of Stuart Fails to Save the Universe reinvents its title sequence, packed with fourth wall-busting messages aimed directly at the viewer, including one that flat-out tells you not to hit skip.
For a show about a comic shop owner, Stuart seems pretty self-aware. And he probably already knows he is being watched.
But here is the question I cannot stop turning over as the season heads toward its late-September finale.
What if Stuart does not just notice the audience? What if he talks back?
A Comic Store Owner Is the Perfect Person to Notice He’s in a Story
Nobody in the Big Bang Theory universe was better positioned to catch on than Stuart.
He ran Comic Center for over a decade, which means multiverse resets, retcons, and characters climbing out of their own panels were never abstract concepts to him.
When a version of Stuart walked in on comic-shop Stuart and handed him a doomed mission, he strangely seemed less than surprised.
It might just be how he reacts to everything, but remember he is the one guy who has spent his whole life reading stories about people trapped inside comic bubbles.
Deadpool built an entire persona around that same awareness, poking at the camera, the writers, and the franchise around him because he always seemed to know more than the story wanted him to.
Stuart has the resume to pull off an understated version of that same trick.
He would not need the wisecracks like Deadpool, where he stops mid-collapse and looks at what is actually going on around him and puts in a sexual joke.
He would simply look at the viewers with his unassuming blinking eyes, the way only a lifelong reader would, slip out an “I know you’re watching,” and simply shrug it off.
The opening credits echo just that. The same kind of self-deprecating, unexpected humor that Stuart and Kevin Sussman thrive on.
And I wouldn’t be too surprised if we get a Spider-Man meme moment towards the end, between the apocalypse Stuart, the main-timeline Stuart, and the 4th-wall-breaking Stuart.
A Fourth Wall Reset Would Actually Fit This Show’s Sense of Humor
It’s not just the opening credits that are fuelling my conviction.
John Ross Bowie revealed at San Diego Comic-Con that the finale is building toward a twist big enough to leave fans reacting hard.
Brian Posehn has said viewers will be left wanting more once the season wraps. What if the twist is the fourth-wall breaking itself?
Combine that with a show that already treats its opening titles as a direct line to the audience, and a finale where Stuart finally turns around and addresses the writers themselves does not feel like a stretch to me.
Picture it. Stuart, having failed to fix the multiverse through force, tech, or borrowed genius from four different Leonards, finally just stops.
He looks past Bert and Denise and Kripke, past the wreckage of whatever timeline they have landed in, and says something to the effect of “Please, just put it back the way it was.”
And you know what would be funnier? If Denise asks at that exact moment: “How did you know it would work?”
And Stuart answering with those same beady, unaware eyes, “I did not.”
Let that be the first instance of Stuart’s fourth-wall-breaking powers, and carry it over to Stuart Fails to Save the Universe Season 2.
Chuck Lorre has confirmed Season 2 is already locked for September 2027, so a full reset would not even need to be permanent.
It could just be the reveal that finally explains why Stuart, of all people, was the one chosen to fix this mess.
He has spent his whole life reading about characters who get to talk back to their own narrative. Maybe the finale finally lets him try it.
Do you think Stuart addresses the camera directly before this season wraps, or am I reading way too much into a title sequence that just really likes messing with the skip button?
Tell me your theory in the comments, and subscribe if you want to find out together when the finale actually drops.
-
Stuart Fails to Save the Universe already winks at its audience through its title sequences, and its comic-connoisseur lead might be building toward a full Deadpool-style break.
-
What could have been a fun episode for Bert was overshadowed by Denise. Stuart Fails to Save the Universe Season 1 Episode 3 is mediocre.
-
While I certainly have questions about the movement from world to world, Stuart Fails to Save the Universe Season 1 Episode 2 remains fun.
TV Fanatic is searching for passionate contributors to share their voices across a variety of different articles. Do you think you have what it takes to be a TV Fanatic? Click here for more information and next steps.
-
Check out our list of the best lines from Star Trek: Strange New Worlds “The Griffin Incident,” Trek’s first foray into the space horror genre
-
From blindsides to big twists, Big Brother is full of iconic moments. We discuss the moments all new fans should know. Read on to find out!
-
From Gilmore Girls to Gossip Girl, these iconic couples were never part of the plan. Here’s how chemistry rewrote the script and gave us TV’s greatest romances.