The Good Physician depicts autism higher than virtually any present at present on TV.
However when it will get it incorrect, it will get it method incorrect.
The Good Doctor Season 3 Episode 16 was a kind of instances. For the second episode in a row, everybody tried to inform Shaun what he felt, and the implication that he does not know his personal emotions was annoying.
Let’s get this straight proper now: autism is not about having no clue what your emotional state is.
Many individuals with autism really feel overwhelmed each by their feelings and by different individuals’s and shut down, however as a rule, they know what they’re feeling.
I do not suppose that is about you shedding a affected person. I believe that is you distracting your self. You do not need to let Jane go since you do not need to let Carly go.
Park
Everybody’s totally different, in fact, so it is conceivable that Shaun is much less in contact along with his feelings than different individuals, autistic or not.
However as a result of he’s the one autistic character on The Good Physician, having him be an autistic one that is clueless about his personal emotional state sends the message that that is what it means to have autism.
Carly broke up with Shaun on The Good Doctor Season 3 Episode 15 as a result of she was satisfied he was in love with Lea though he insisted he wasn’t.
That was obnoxious sufficient with out Carly turning out to be proper, once more sending the message that neurotypical individuals know what autistic individuals really feel higher than autistic individuals do.
Plus, the scenes with Carly and Lea proved that Carly is significantly better for Shaun than Lea is, apart from her ridiculous jealousy of Lea.
I could not assist considering that Shaun had satisfied himself he was “extra in love” with Lea, as a result of it did not appear to be it.
It appeared like he was in love with Carly however took her command actually to say he was in love with Lea.
When he went to Carly for what gave the impression to be a work-related objective, there was chemistry, which merely doesn’t exist with Lea. As well as, Shaun was reluctant to depart Carly and appeared into her eyes like he needed to kiss her.
But he advised Glassman that he needed to be with Lea and could not take care of the potential for her rejecting him.
It is clear the writers supposed for Carly to be a placeholder whereas Shaun got here to the “realization” that he was meant to be with Lea, however Shaun’s actions on-screen do not recommend that in any respect.
Lea has all the time been the comfy, protected selection for Shaun regardless of the chaos she brings into his life. He does not should push previous his consolation zone and do the onerous work required to make a relationship work with Lea like he does with Carly.
Even Lea’s response to Shaun’s admission of affection demonstrated how mismatched and higher off as mates these two are.
Lea is conscious of how immature and drama-addicted she is, however that does not make her proper for Shaun, and she or he could not even keep to complete the dialog when he requested her if she was rejecting him as a result of he had autism.
Conversely, Shaun and Carly talk. They speak by means of issues. They push by means of the tough patches.
They usually problem each other.
Let’s hope Shaun realizes this quickly and will get again along with Carly.
The medical circumstances have been way more fascinating than the romantic drama.
Shaun’s quest to seek out out what killed his Jane Doe was particularly compelling. Everybody assumed that he was simply distracting himself from the breakup with Carly, however understanding Shaun, it was extra seemingly he was simply participating in some autistic hyperfocus on a brand new case.
Shaun: Carly broke up with me.
Melendez: I assumed you two have been doing nice.
Shaun: We have been, however then we weren’t. Cross clamp, please.
Park: You could actually be hurting.
Shaun: Probably not.
Melendez: We have all been there. It helps whenever you personal you are in ache.
Shaun: There may be nothing for me to personal as a result of I am wonderful.
His makes an attempt to speak to Jules went badly, to say the least, and he’s fortunate Jules did not name the cops once more the second he confirmed up.
But it surely appeared like Shaun’s final phrases to Jules about how Jules’ mom did love him got here from a deep place, and Shaun may need, on some stage, been considering of his personal tumultuous relationship along with his late father.
Aiden and alter-Aiden have been a novel sort of dissociative case.
Dissociative Id Dysfunction is usually misrepresented on TV, but when The Good Physician had gone there, it most likely would have been extra correct than most.
Nevertheless, the collection went in a extra unique route by having Aiden’s dissociative issues be brought on by a cyst in his mind.
Morgan was annoying as regular…till alter-Aiden wanted a push to make the suitable choice.
So are you and Melendez again to sneaking round? I hear he is gone again to being a very good mentor. Apparently my criticism did nothing.
Morgan
Hopefully, her insistence on doing issues like submitting complaints as a result of she’s jealous will come again to chew her ultimately.
Lim already spoke to her about that, so it can most likely harm her professionally sooner or later.
But when I have been Claire, I would watch out about having any form of friendship with Morgan after her betrayal And that is a disgrace, as a result of their friendship makes Morgan tolerable.
Anyway, Morgan was the one to get by means of to alter-Aiden, so she was semi-redeemed, however we do not want any extra of her petty jealousy, or of Claire and Melendez pretending to battle for her profit.
Melendez and Lim sneaking round after they have been relationship was dangerous sufficient. There is no want for Melendez and Claire to sneak round to have a platonic relationship.
Talking of Lim, that was an odd storyline with that little lady.
For the primary half of the episode, I assumed the kid was a figment of her creativeness. I am glad that wasn’t the case, although the entire thing was bizarre.
Lim had nice rapport with the kid, although, and her phrases about how a lot love the guts can maintain tied in properly with Shaun and Jules’ story.
Hearts are wonderful issues. I’ve held one in my fingers many instances. You’d by no means know by them, however one way or the other they’ve all of the room we’d like.
Lim
I’d have liked to have recognized about this backstory for Lim earlier than Trinity confirmed up, but it surely turned out to be a touching story, even when it was somewhat bit unusual.
Your flip, Good Physician fanatics.
What’s your tackle Shaun’s relationship drama, the circumstances of the hour, and all different issues Good Physician?
Hit SHOW COMMENTS and share your ideas.
Wish to see the episode once more? You may watch The Good Doctor online proper right here on TV Fanatic.
The Good Physician continues to air on ABC on Mondays at 10 PM EST/PST.
Jack Ori is a senior workers author for TV Fanatic. Observe him on Twitter.