The Disney+ collection, The Proper Stuff, is about trailblazers, however as a TV present, it stands in a crowd.
Reveals about astronauts and area companies appear to be again in vogue as a result of For All Mankind, Area Pressure, Away, and Moonbase Eight made their debuts, too.
Mega franchises, Star Trek and Star Wars proceed to boldly go and discover a galaxy far, distant.
And because the 1983 movie model is beloved and iconic, the comparisons between the 2 have been inevitable.
But, as I used to be watching The Proper Stuff, I wasn’t evaluating it to any of these different exhibits or the movie. What I saved being reminded of, and wished to observe as a substitute, was HBO’s From The Earth To The Moon.
Produced by Ron Howard and Tom Hanks (who additionally directed and acted in it), From The Earth To The Moon was HBO’s 1998 mini-series chronicling the U.S. area program from NASA’s response to Yuri Gagarin turning into the primary man in area to the final Apollo mission.
When it comes to depicting the occasions from the area race, there is not numerous direct overlap between the 2 collection (this might change relying on whether or not The Proper Stuff lasts for greater than a season and chooses to transcend its supply materials).
The Right Stuff Season 1 Episode 1 opens with Alan Shepard and John Glenn making ready for Shepard’s launch.
Many of the season is about catching the viewers up on the astronauts’ journey to that day. Then the launch and flight happen on the season finale, The Proper Stuff Season 1 Episode 8.
Throughout the first 20 minutes of From The Earth To The Moon Season 1 Episode 1, Al Shepard goes into area and comes again to Earth.
There’s extra overlap by way of characters: Alan Shepard, Wally Schirra, Gus Grissom, Deke Slayton, and others are featured on each collection. In evaluating how each collection painting the characters, one thing turns into apparent. From The Earth To The Moon’s characters are much more memorable.
From The Earth To The Moon boasts an enormous forged, and lots of roles are bit elements consisting of a few scenes and some strains. Even so, these characters seize your consideration and depart an impression.
Characters like Deke Slayton and Gus Grissom seem on each episode of The Right Stuff Season 1. After watching all eight episodes, I nonetheless had a tough time distinguishing Slayton from Grissom.
Wally Schirra can be one of many Mercury 7, however he is one of many least targeted upon characters. Not even pranking Glenn on The Right Stuff Season 1 Episode 3 did a lot to make him a extra fleshed out character.
Schirra solely seems on From The Earth To The Moon Season 1 Episode 3, however he is charismatic and dynamic, and when the credit roll, you’re feeling like you recognize every little thing concerning the man.
One thing else dragging down The Proper Stuff is the selection to construct the collection round Shepard and Glenn’s rivalry over who would be the first American in area. It brings out the worst in each characters. It is repetitive. It is as thrilling as watching paint dry.
Now, it is not like From The Earth To The Moon did not contact upon the rivalries among the many astronauts or depicted them as by no means caring about being the person who goes down within the historical past books.
From The Earth To The Moon Season 1 Episode 6 is the episode most much like The Proper Stuff as a result of the battle between Neil Armstrong and Buzz Aldrin over who steps onto the moon first may be very harking back to the battle between Shepard and Glenn.
The distinction is From The Earth To The Moon executes it higher. For one factor, the Armstrong and Aldrin battle solely lasts for an episode. It is one-sided, and the characters are extra sympathetic.
Armstrong’s focus is on attending to the moon slightly than turning into the primary man to stroll on it, which makes him all of the extra admirable. Aldrin obsesses about who must be first, however the script and Bryan Cranston’s portrayal invite you to empathize with Aldrin slightly than flip towards him.
It is an amazing episode of TV, however it’s not From The Earth To The Moon’s greatest episode. The dignity belongs to From The Earth To The Moon Season 1 Episode 7, and it’s the antithesis of The Proper Stuff.
The Proper Stuff is cynical and dour. From The Earth To The Moon Season 1 Episode 7 — depicting the Apollo 12 mission — is hilarious and enjoyable.
The Proper Stuff retains speaking about how Shepard and Glenn are above everybody else, however they arrive throughout as petty and egocentric.
From The Earth To The Moon emphasizes how the Apollo 12 crew shouldn’t be so completely different from the remainder of us, and it makes all of them the extra extraordinary.
The Proper Stuff endorses an “each man for himself” perspective. From The Earth To The Moon Season 1 Episode 7 tells us that nothing, not even going to the moon, issues if you cannot share it with those you like.
Love, optimism, and surprise are prevalent themes on From The Earth To The Moon. The enjoyment of exploring the universe makes the collection thrilling to observe time and again. The absence of it on The Proper Stuff makes the latter colder than area.
Over to you, TV Fanatics!
Are you a fan of The Proper Stuff?
How does it stack up towards different TV exhibits about astronauts?
Hit the feedback beneath.
Becca Newton is a workers author for TV Fanatic.