Star Trek: Discovery Season 1 Episode 2 Assessment: From First Officer to First Mutineer

Spoilers

The place the premiere oriented the viewers (considerably) within the right here and now of Burnham and the Shenzhou’s crew, Star Trek: Discovery Season 1 Episode 2 is extra involved with the place they got here from.

It additionally spends a substantial amount of effort to additional construct credibility for this collection within the Trek ‘verse.

With the battle ramping up dramatically, we get glimpses of assorted Klingon and Starfleet vessels and their respective crews.

The cinematic glory is fairly spectacular.

And it is not simply the tech and the politics that make us really feel at house. Earlier than there was Picard, earlier than there was Kirk, earlier than there was STAR FLEET, there was Sarek.

What an excellent transfer to tie ST: Discovery into the ‘verse with somebody we have really met earlier than. Repeatedly.

In any case, this is not Star Wars the place they will simply throw in an early model of R2 or C-3PO to provide us the twinges of nostalgia. They tapped into it right here with Spock’s freakin’ DAD. If Sarek is in the home, that is correct Trek.

Sarek: So a few years and you continue to permit emotional concerns to impede your logic.
Burnham: They INFORM my logic.

I discovered it bizarre to look at James Frain NOT being a villain however as soon as I obtained previous it, I appreciated his faithfulness to the canon and his respect for the character.

Ambassador Sarek has at all times related with people. That he thoughts melds with Michael Burnham to avoid wasting her life as a baby after which raises her on Vulcan just isn’t a stretch of the creativeness in any respect.

That he rolls round in her head on a regular basis and might detect her imminent demise from a distant star system requires slightly extra suspension of disbelief. 

I appreciated seeing his try and ease her into her life with Starfleet, personally escorting her and introducing her to Georgiou.

She does not make it straightforward, in any case. Her Vulcan upbringing is sort of extra off-putting as a result of she is human.

Respect is earned. As is friendliness.

Burnham

Georgiou is sort of bemused by the prickliness of the younger Burnham. There is a mentor-apprentice vibe from the beginning, not stunning as we have already seen the captain deal with her as her protégée on Star Trek: Discovery Season 1 Episode 1.

I imply, earlier than Burnham Vulcan nerve pinched her and Georgiou needed to throw her within the brig.

Talking of the brig. Is it actually believable that one can discuss the pc out of it is programming? I might suppose the circuits would fry first.

To make certain, Starfleet ships most likely aren’t programmed by Vulcans however then once more, they might be.

And Burnham had Sarek in her nook so perhaps he tweaked the logic button in her head whereas he was in there.

Irrespective of your disgrace, collect your power. Discover a method to assist those that want you.

Sarek

It is also fairly clear that Georgiou by no means supposed on Burnham spending a lot time within the brig, seeing how rapidly she welcomed her enter as soon as she’d made her method again to the bridge.

The collaboration with Saru permits the Kelpian some fascinating character reveals.

Saru: We’ve photon torpedoes. We will not fireplace them however we are able to load the battle heads onto a transport, one sufficiently small to evade their sensors. Upon impression, we might ship a kill shot immediately into their hull.
Georgiou: Devious, Saru. I approve.

Nevertheless it was at all times meant to be The Georgiou and Burnham Present. Each hero’s journey entails shedding the mentor early on. That Burnham can realistically place that loss on her personal shoulders solely provides to the bags she’ll carry ahead.

In not very refined parallelism, we see T’Kuvma and Voq enjoying out an identical relationship because the Klingons circle the wagons.

Whereas Georgiou and Burnham are attempting to defend the Federation and Starfleet’s ideas, T’Kuvma is concurrently inciting the Klingons to unity beneath his management and energetic aggression in the direction of all outsiders.

“Messiah Complicated” is not understating the state of affairs as that’s precisely what he purports to be.

You solely dwell now to function witnesses of Klingon supremacy, to be my heralds. We don’t want to know you however you’ll know our nice homes standing as one beneath Kahless, reborn in me, T’Kuvma!

T’Kuvma

It is an irony not misplaced on me that Burnham’s whole take-him-prisoner plan is formulated to stop Georgiou from turning him right into a martyr after which she herself does precisely that.

T’Kuvma’s rallying name to Klingons is surprisingly inclusive.

With most Klingons fast to activate any outliers, as fractured because the inhabitants is amongst their many homes — and I might like to see an organizational chart of what every home’s experience is — T’Kuvma’s chosen, Voq, is a visible aberrant and a societal outcast.

There is no such thing as a honor with out unity. There is no such thing as a house for any of us, except it’s shared by all.

T’Kuvma

That he loses his mentor and messiah mere breaths after Burnham loses hers is telling.

We are going to see extra of him.

And that is actually our place to begin. 

We’ve a Star Trek collection the place the central character just isn’t the captain, could by no means be a captain.

Burnham is a flawed particular person who has made horrendous errors in judgement.

She carries trauma along with her in addition to (most likely) buried insecurities she has masked with Vulcan logic and stoicism.

She has misplaced her mentor. Her father-figure is at nice distance and with out the power to mediate the punishment for her crime.

And, two hours into the collection, now we have but to see the ship it’s named after.

Curiouser and curiouser.

We’re left in a bizarre form of lurch after what quantities to a prologue to the collection. 

There’s a battle. There was demise. 

Each the Federation and the Klingons are in a chaotic state of affairs.

From my youth on Vulcan, I used to be raised to imagine that service was my objective. And I carried that conviction to Star Fleet. I dreamed of a day once I would command my very own vessel and additional the noble aims of this nice establishment. My dream is over. The one ship I do know in ruins. My crew… gone. My captain, my good friend. I wished to guard them from battle, from the enemy. And we’re at battle and I’m the enemy.

Burnham

And Burnham is a prisoner, a legal within the eyes of Starfleet and herself.

Star Trek has solely sometimes represented Federation war-time eventualities. The Dominion Warfare of Deep House 9 is the one which comes readily to thoughts, adopted most likely by Enterprise’s Temporal Warfare.

Right here, we’re thrust right into a battle which will be assumed would be the driving power of the plot, affecting ships, crew members, and relationships.

And, on the middle, is a failed officer, a mutineer, a human raised by Vulcans who kills Klingons.

The place does this rabbit gap lead subsequent?

Diana Keng is a employees author for TV Fanatic. Comply with her on Twitter.

Articles You May Like

Chris Combs Shares His Private Mental Health Journey
Pretty Little Liars: Summer School Season 1 Episode 3 Review: Sweet Sixteen
Sullivan’s Crossing – Secrets – Review: Things Come to a Head
Carrie Preston’s Long and Enjoyable Road to Lead Lady
‘Elsbeth’ Star Wendell Pierce Says Wagner’s Major Decision Is Emotional & Strategic